← Back to All Articles Choose Agent

How Do I Choose the Right Listing Agent in McKinney?

Say you have three McKinney agents coming through this week and all three pitches sound the same. The one worth hiring is the one who can show you their pricing math and their actual marketing, not just tell you about it.

McKinney right now makes that easy to test. Homes are being listed at a median around $593,000 while closings over the last 30 days came in near $511,000, down about 3.5 percent from the same stretch last year. That gap between asking and getting is the whole job. An agent who cannot explain it is going to learn it on your listing.

What should I ask about their pricing plan?

Ask for the comps before you ask for the number. Any agent can arrive with a price. Fewer can show you the six or eight closed sales they built it from, why they picked those, and which ones they threw out.

Then ask the follow-up that actually matters: what happens if it does not sell in three weeks. You want to hear a plan with dates and triggers in it, not "we will reassess." If their answer to a slow start is a price cut and nothing else, they do not have a strategy, they have a lever.

• Which comps did you use, and which did you reject?
• What did those homes list at versus close at?
• At what point do we change something, and what changes first?

Can they show me their own marketing?

This is the fastest way to separate agents. Ask to see the last three listings they marketed. Not a brochure about their services. The actual photos, the actual video, the actual listing copy that went out.

Picture two agents on the same McKinney house. One shoots it on a phone in the afternoon and writes four lines of description. The other brings a real photographer, a drone for the lot and the neighborhood, and a walkthrough video that a buyer three states away can watch before booking a flight. Same house, and the second one gets seen by more people.

If an agent cannot produce their own recent work on request, that tells you what your listing is going to get.

How do I judge their read on the McKinney market?

Ask about your side of town specifically, not McKinney as a whole. The market near downtown does not behave like new construction out west, and an agent who talks about all of McKinney as one number is working off a headline.

Good signs: they know what has closed recently within a mile of you, they know what is sitting, and they will tell you which of the two your house looks more like. An agent who only has good news is not reading the market, they are selling you the listing.

Does the commission rate decide it?

It should be part of the decision, not the whole thing. The math is simple enough to run yourself. On a $500,000 sale, a half point of commission is $2,500. If the cheaper agent prices the house wrong and you sit for two extra months before cutting, you gave back far more than $2,500 in carrying costs and negotiating position.

Cheap is only cheap if the outcome is the same. Ask both agents what they spend on photography, video, and paid exposure per listing, and whether that comes out of their side or yours. Sometimes a lower rate is a lower rate. Sometimes it is a smaller marketing budget wearing a discount.

Interview at least two, ask all of them for their comps and their last three listings, and hire the one whose plan you could repeat back to a friend.

AI-assisted research and drafting, reviewed and approved by Ben Jimenez before publishing.